Friday, January 9, 2009

Calling All Lurkers

Recently I had an e-mail from someone at church whom I admire very much. In it, she said "Here are some of my thoughts on your blog post about Mark 10 that I was too chicken to post there..."

I was really surprised. First, because it's always interesting to find out who reads my blog. But also because it never occurred to me that anyone would feel uncomfortable commenting on a blog. I comment often on people's blogs. Russ almost never comments on blogs. The sociologist in me is fascinated by this disparity and my inquiring mind wants to know more.

I know that I am at a disadvantage in trying to understand why people read a blog and never comment. As an very extroverted person, I am interested in what people have to say and assume that they are equally interested in hearing what I have to say. It is also relatively easy for me to think through things on my feet (or fingers!), so to speak, which my more introverted friends assure me is not the case with them.

I want to know--if you are a lurker and not a commenter (on this or any other blog), why? I've put a poll on the right hand side of my blog and I'm asking you to at least answer the poll. If you have more to say about why you do or do not comment, feel free to leave a comment on this post!

19 comments:

  1. I live with a lady right now that gets annoyed if I comment on her stories. She'll tell me a story of growing up in Idaho, and I'll listen and then when she's done I'd say "I had a similar experience in Idaho..." And tell my story. I thought I was sharing and building a relatonship on common beliefs or experiences (like I was taught in the MTC). However she saw it as me being competative. She says I was trying to out do her story with a better story. So now, I just listen to her stories and then go back to my room. And I'm fearful that maybe others have found me to be competative - so I don't comment on as many blogs as I used to. (Though truth be told - I only activily follow three written blogs and two photo blogs.)

    If I don't comment on Cindy's or yours it's usually because I don't feel I have anything to add or I'm too busy to write what I would really like to write. I don't comment on Nie Nie's blog because there are like 400 people that comment all saying the same basic thing and I don't feel like adding to that.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I would say I go in between. I like to comment if I have something clever enough to say. If not...I just lurk. I love it when people comment on my blog.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sean--so sad when people just want to tell their stuff without sharing yours as well. I'd much rather build a relationship too. And you are always welcome to comment here! I totally get what you mean about not commenting on blogs where hundreds of people comment. I guess I feel like at that point it wouldn't even make a difference!

    Audrey, I know what you mean too. I hate it if I want to say something but just can't figure out the right thing...

    ReplyDelete
  4. When I blurk (my friend's term for lurking on a blog and not commenting) it is either that I have nothing to add or that I don't have time just then. But I do try and comment whenever I can. I enjoy reading comments on my blog, so I like to do the same.

    Your blog is a nice mix of deep thinking and fun stuff, so I enjoy coming here. I also like the Q&A that goes on in the comment section and come back often to read anything new.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Ok Cindy, I'm guilty of being a lurker. I love reading your blog but had never figured out how to comment so today I signed up and got an ID so I could comment. I got hooked on Cindy Lynn's blog and that naturally led to yours. I guess I really don't comment because we don't really know each other that well, although I must say I feel like I know you a little better now through the blog. Keep the stories coming!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Way to go, Sharon! You know, even some of my closest friends have said they feel like they know more about what's going on in my life now that I have a blog. I'm glad you enjoy my blog, and of course I think CL's blog is wonderful!

    ReplyDelete
  7. And have you noticed that there's commenting etiquette....like if someone comments on a post of yours, you should really go comment on one of theirs. I haven't been so good at that lately because half the time I've got a baby in one arm.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Katie--I'm not sure how I feel about commenting etiquette. I am not sure I feel the need for someone to comment just to be commenting, kwim? I'd rather people comment because they have something to say. Or because they love me. That works too. ;)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Commenting etiquette? I think I missed that memo.

    And from one extrovert to another, thanks for this post. It's always interesting to learn about someone else and see something from another (introverted) perspective.

    And speaking of extroverts, would you believe that my mother will not comment on my blog -- or MommyJ's either? She, too, sends me an e-mail to share her thoughts about my posts.

    Maybe if we all heckle her together, she will stop blurking (I LOVE this word!) and start putting forth her two cents worth into the blogosphere.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Don't tell her (ok I am right now) but I haunt CL's blog, but I don't really dare make comments because she doesn't know me, even though I knew her when she was a newborn (such a cute newborn too!) And since i am fessing up, what is Mahon's middle name? Please tell me it's not....?

    Somehow lurker has a bad connotation I think I would rather haunt blogs :). I read a lot of blogs. I keep mine locked up because I am a privacy freak and with legal issues this fall it was necessary so I have only like 6 readers of my blog and I only comment on those readers blogs usually. I can't keep up. If i ask for follow up comments to be emailed I get swamped with emails, if I don't then I miss the back and forth. How do you handle it?

    ReplyDelete
  11. I totally agree with audrey. I'm trying to be better about leaving some sort of comment even if it's simple just to show I was there because I LOVE receiving comments on my blog.

    As silly as it sounds, CindyLynn's little "add your two cents" invitation always reassures me that all comments clever or simple are welcome. :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. InkMom--I think part of this is an issue of age. Momster & I are the same age, and I think we're in the minority, certainly Sharon is much more tech-savvy than most people her age. If you think about it, Cindy Lynn's generation is used to letting it all hang out on their facebook wall. Our parent's generation didn't do anything "publicly" like that. So I can understand your mom commenting privately, although I am sure she has such words of wisdom to add that she should comment publicly!

    Momster, I think CL would be flattered that you read her blog. Aren't we all? I personally love having conversation through the comments, so I like the e-mail feature. I think one solution on being swamped with follow-up e-mails is to have them filtered into a folder in your e-mail. That way when you want to check them you can, but they don't come in with your regular e-mail.

    Megan--that's a great way to look at it. I usually feel like I don't need to leave a comment on every post, but I do want people to know I was there and enjoyed their blog. And let's be (extrovertedly) honest. When don't I have something to say!?!?!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hey! Anyone is WELCOME to leave comments on my blog. Me knowing who you are is not a requirement.

    And Mahon's middle name is... Benjamin.

    ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Interesting post! You've made me think a little...

    It seems like I comment 'every once in a while' - either when I have something to say, or when I feel like I haven't commented on that person's blog for a while. But, I do notice that I comment on EVERY post of some of the blogs that don't update very regularly, and I only comment on SOME posts when the blogger is posting a lot. Maybe I just feel like, if I don't have anything exceptionally interesting to add to a regularly updated blog, they'll post something soon enough that I WILL have something to say on. :)

    But, you're right - I sure LOVE comments on my blog...even if they consist of only a few words!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thank you Cindy (and CL)! I like to think I know what I am doing on the computer but how to filter email from blogger into a folder w/o having my other email going into the folder is beyond me-could you give me a hint. On one computer I use gmail and on the other I use mozilla thunderbird as my email client.
    And CL I am relieved to hear about the Benjamin :). You said its ok if people who don't know you comment on your blog---thats part of why I don't comment---I feel like I do know you since I have known your parents for your entire life and have heard about you for your entire life and by virtue of that loved you your entire life <3 A bit scary?

    ReplyDelete
  16. Yeah - when Mahon and I were dating my roommate's favorite thing to do was introduce him like this:

    "This is my roommate Cindy and this is her friend Mahon. His real name is Mahonri. Can you guess what his middle name is?"

    "....Moriancumer?"

    "NO! Benjamin!"

    It brought her endless delight.

    And hey - I just like it when people comment on my blog. ;)

    ReplyDelete
  17. I commented on Cindy Lynn's blog long before we met. I now comment on Cindy Mom's blog and we won't probably ever meet (unless I get accepted to grad school in NC and then I'm going to make plans of sleeping on the front lawn.) Neither one of these people have hated me because of my commenting. In fact - I even got invited to Cindy & Mahon's wedding reception and I got Cindy to free web design for me for my awesome teaching sean blog.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Wow, quite impressive Cindy! Let me think, why do I comment or not comment? Sometimes, I don't comment because I'm busy, or have been following their blogging and don't really want to seem like I have been following their blogging? I know that sounds funny, but in the same breath, I love comments on our blog, and to see how things come across to others. I generally make sure I comment when I'm very moved either almost to tears, or laughing out of my seat. And sometimes I just comment cuz I think I should.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Oh, I just thought of something else. I think that comments are a bit like Christmas cards. I love tangible Christmas cards, something in the mail that isn't a bill and actually conveys how people are, at least a little bit. I think comments are a little like that, letting you know that someone is thinking of you and cares enough to take a second to let you know. That being said, I should probably comment more?

    ReplyDelete