Friday, October 16, 2009

What Say Ye About Facebook?

While I was on vacation this summer several different people that I was visiting with told me how bothered they are by Facebook. I am personally ambivalent about Facebook, and my computer really hates facebook so it's difficult for me to spend much time on it. But I was surprised to hear such strong opinions expressed against it.

Later I read an article in the Wall Street Journal called How Facebook Can Ruin Your Friendships. Apparently my friends aren't the only ones with Facebook issues.

But then several days later Cindy Lynn pointed me in the direction of an article on Salon.com called Is the Internet melting our Brains? This article asserts that every communication advancement throughout human history, from the pencil to the typewriter to writing itself, has been met with fear, skepticism and a longing for the medium that's been displaced. He also believes that social networking sites, blogs and the Internet are actually making us better writers and improving our ability to reach out to our fellow man.

So where do you stand on Facebook? Love it, hate it, or somewhere inbetween?

11 comments:

  1. You know my stance...actually, it's funny, when I shut down my page, it randomly picked five of my friends and flashed their pictures with a little caption underneath saying "so and so will miss you!" You were one of them, and that's when I was like, "Nice try facebook, I see Cindy all the time!"

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting topic...I like the article about ruining friendships. It has some valid points- maybe I don't want to know what certain people are doing, or eating or not doing! But I think you can avoid that my choosing your facebook friends wisely!

    I like facebook! Wouldn't say I love it, but I like it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hate it. But still do it. Minimally. I do not status update. I do not check it daily -- or even weekly. I occasionally use it to get in touch with someone I don't usually need to contact. But still hate it. All those newsfeed items? Should I really care that you just found a lonely pink cow in farmville? I think things like Facebook and Twitter and even blogging, to an extent, turn people into narcissists because there is an inherent assumption that yes, there are people out there interested in a detailed play by play of every day of our lives. Even if there are, in reality, a grand total of zero people reading our status updates, we begin to focus so much on what other people might think about our lives that we stop being "real".

    So that's my piece.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I liked the 3 comments left so far. It can be intrusive (if we let it), it can ridiculous (IE, the status thing), the quizzes and remarks are WAY over the top (and gives other people way too much info on someone, which could be misused). InkMom's comment about the narcissist's thinking everyone wants to know or cares about every little thing in their life...isn't it like blogging, just the lazy way? Haha...it's like most things...depends on how you use it! Or it uses you!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Are you sure I sent you that?? LOL! I tend to err on the side of "melting your brain" most of the time. That said, Facebook quite possibly just kept me from getting the seasonal flu, so I am feeling loyal to Facebook today.

    I use Facebook because, sadly, a lot my peers don't use email anymore in favor of Faceboook. And I agree with InkMom and Mindy - EVERYTHING about the internet right now is inherently narcissistic.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The biggest problem I see with facebook, texting, IM'ing, etc is that 80% of communication is body language, voice inflections, etc...That leaves only 20% to the actual words someone is speaking. That leaves whole lot of interpretation, or misinterpretation when you are only reading what a person in saying.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ooooooh, I kind of have a soap-box about Facebook. I love the previous comments, and feel much of the same way. I didn't read the article yet, but I'm definitely not surprised that facebook can ruin friendships...I think if I knew what every single person in my life was doing with everyone else, I'd probably start to feel left out of the things in which I wasn't included, more than appreciating the things of which I AM included. I have other qualms with it...but I do love it for the fact that I've reconnected with some grade-school friends that I never would have found otherwise! It just seems like whenever I spend time on Facebook, I come away feeling like I've just wasted a bunch of time. The same could be true of blogs...but most of the time I come away from reading blogs thinking about something interesting or feeling like I've just learned something valuable about someone else - - - not just that they finished cleaning their house today.

    ReplyDelete
  8. You probably already know how I feel about facebook... in moderation, I think it is great. I get to keep in touch with friends from efy or friends who live on the other side of the country, along with having a deeper relationship with my friends here in NC. Solution to the meaningless status messages: I skip most of them :D

    ReplyDelete
  9. Moderation in all things. I think it's totally what you let it become. I think it's fun to know what people are up to and I actually think it can be fun to here the more "trivial" things that people might be up to. I've been able to reconnect with lots of friends from other countries and stay in touch with friends that I am FAR away from.
    Of course there are ridiculous things and stuff I could care less about. Also, there are ways to set up who you actually want updates on. I certainly don't think it should become anyone's ONE form of communication with others, but I think it can be a great supplement.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I like it. I have reconnected with some long lost friends...really long lost like my best buddy in elementary school! I spend more time on it now that I sit and nurse. I will be on less when Kailynn gets more mobile. For me it is the best way to keep up with my family and post kid pictures and videos. Most are set to friend view only. My sister loves that she gets to watch the baby on video. When daddy travels, which is a lot recently he checks for new pictures too and I try to get them up so he can see at least the baby.

    So for me it is useful. Like anything though it can be misused.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Now that I've figured out how to use all the filters for my newsfeed, I quite like it. But I don't love it because it's time consuming. My favorite thing is finding long-lost friends that I would have never heard from again otherwise.

    ReplyDelete